Stiff shaft for a beginner?
Like Tom Wishon (who I think knows a thing or two about shafts) said:
From a pure shaft performance standpoint, 90 percent of you are goingto be better off with a shaft that is more flexible than what you think youneed.
There's 3 problems that come with shafts that are too stiff, that will negatively affect you (generally, but especially as a beginner):
Shorter flight - most beginners don't hit it too far anyway, so an additional distance loss hurts even more
Lower flight - a ball flight that's too high typically isn't a problem for beginners, not being able to hold the green is
Fade tendency - with a fade/slice being the typical beginner problem, increasing that tendency doesn't help
And here are the downsides of a shaft that's too flexible:
Higher (and possibly farther) ball flight - I haven't seen a beginner that struggles with ballooning balls, yet...
Draw tendency - if you're not already fighting a hook/strong draw, this shot shape bias may actually be welcome.
Let me sum up the two options by quoting Mr. Wishon again:
Of the two, choosing thesecond choice is a no brainer.